Start free
Menu

Comparison

Capstan and BrightHR

BrightHR is a serious product, and this page is not a scorecard. It sets out how each of the two is built, taking each side from how it is publicly positioned, and then gives you the questions worth putting to any vendor in this market, us included. Where BrightHR is the better buy, it says so, and it says where Capstan is the wrong choice outright.

What each one is built to be

Start here rather than with a feature list. Most of the difference between two HR products is decided before either one ships a feature, by what business the company is in.

BrightHR, as publicly positioned, October 2026

BrightHR presents itself as HR software for small and mid-sized businesses whose distinctive edge is bundled employment-law and HR advice, backed by its parent, the Peninsula Group. The centre of gravity is day-to-day people-management admin, absence and leave, rota and shift scheduling, time tracking through its clock-in app, documents and reporting, wrapped with a round-the-clock employment-law advice line and a template library. It publishes editions for the United Kingdom, Ireland, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, with the United Kingdom its home market.

Capstan, published on this site

Capstan is an HR system of record for companies that employ their own people. It holds the roster, the employment, leave, attendance, documents and the workflows around them, with the module suite included on every plan for the rest. It is not an employer of record, it computes no payroll, and it runs as a self-contained stack in one EU region live today, data in Frankfurt and compute in Amsterdam.

Set out in full on the product page, with the residency model on security and every figure on pricing.

Three structural differences

One axis at a time, two published models, each stated as what it is. Nothing here says what BrightHR does not do: their model is theirs to describe, and if it moves, the line about ours still holds.

  1. What the product is built around

    BrightHR, as publicly positioned, October 2026

    HR administration paired with expert advice is the published offer. The software handles absence and leave, rota and shift scheduling, time tracking and documents, and the distinctive part is a round-the-clock employment-law advice line staffed by qualified advisors and backed by the Peninsula Group, so what you buy is software together with advice.

    Capstan, published on this site

    Capstan is a system of record and the workflow around it, with all fourteen modules included on every plan. It is a product rather than an advisory service: the employment-law judgement stays with your own advisers, and Capstan is the record they and you work from.

  2. Where it is built to work, and how residency is settled

    BrightHR, as publicly positioned, October 2026

    The product is published as country editions, for the United Kingdom, Ireland, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, with the advice rooted in each market and the United Kingdom its home ground.

    Capstan, published on this site

    Capstan is written global-first and carries no jurisdiction-specific content in code, which is what lets it be the same product wherever your team sits. Your data runs in one self-contained EU region, data in Frankfurt and compute in Amsterdam, with no region chooser.

  3. How the offer is shaped

    BrightHR, as publicly positioned, October 2026

    The software is sold per employee with the advice line alongside it and a health-and-safety product offered as well, so what you run is a bundle of software and services sized to your business.

    Capstan, published on this site

    One product, the whole platform on every plan including the free one, all fourteen modules at one per-seat price, billed month to month with no annual contract and no lock-in, and every figure on one public page.

The six questions to ask any vendor, including us

Our answers are here in public with nothing rounded off. The slot beside each one is left open on purpose: BrightHR’s answers are theirs to give, and a comparison page that fills them in has stopped being a comparison. Ask them the same six, and set what you are told beside ours.

  1. Who employs our people, and who carries the liability?

    It decides who is on the contract of employment, who answers a labour authority, and what you are actually buying: a service that takes the employment on, or a system that records it.

    Capstan’s answer, in public

    You do. Capstan is not an employer of record, never becomes the legal employer of anyone on your roster, and moves no payroll money. If you need a legal employer in a country where you have no entity, that is a different kind of vendor.

    BrightHR’s answer

    Ask them, and get it in writing.

  2. Who computes payroll, and whose name is on the filing?

    Computation and filing are where liability sits. A vendor that calculates and files is taking that on. A vendor that prepares inputs is not, and you need the second half of the arrangement in place before you rely on either.

    Capstan’s answer, in public

    Not Capstan, by design. It compiles joiners and leavers, pay structures, leave, attendance and adjustments into a documented export for your payroll partner, and files the computed results back onto the employee record. It holds no statutory rate, slab or formula, and files nothing with any authority.

    BrightHR’s answer

    Ask them, and get it in writing.

  3. Where does our data live, and who inside the vendor can reach it?

    Residency is a property of where the database is, not of a promise in a policy. Support access is the same question from the other end: not whether staff would look, but whether the system lets them without you switching it on.

    Capstan’s answer, in public

    One isolated region, the EU today: data in Frankfurt, compute in Amsterdam. It is a self-contained stack with no global control plane and no cross-region keys, so there is no runtime path out of the region. Staff hold no tenant of their own, and access exists only while you have granted a time-boxed consent, masked by default and audited on both sides.

    BrightHR’s answer

    Ask them, and get it in writing.

  4. What do we get on the plan we start on, and what changes as we grow?

    This is what growing costs you. If capability moves between tiers, the upgrade you eventually buy is largely software you were already being shown.

    Capstan’s answer, in public

    The complete core is on every plan, including the free one, which is capped at twenty active employees. Paying lifts the cap and includes all fourteen modules at no extra charge, billed month to month with no annual contract and no lock-in. Every figure is on one public page, so you can total your own number without a call.

    BrightHR’s answer

    Ask them, and get it in writing.

  5. What happens to our data the day we leave, or the day a payment fails?

    Export is the price of leaving. Either it is written down before you join, or it gets decided at the moment you have the least leverage you will ever have.

    Capstan’s answer, in public

    An owner can take a full export at any time: one archive of JSON and CSV, in open formats, with a documented manifest. Export deliberately sits outside the suspension check, so a workspace held for non-payment can still be exported. Deletion is cryptographic erasure followed by hard deletion, with a residue scan.

    BrightHR’s answer

    Ask them, and get it in writing.

  6. Does any software judge our people, and can the person see why?

    Whether software scores, ranks or screens people decides who is accountable for the judgement, and whether the person it was made about can be shown the reason.

    Capstan’s answer, in public

    No AI scores, ranks or screens your people, and that is architectural rather than a promise: nothing of the kind is built, and the analytics engine can only ever narrow who sees what, with small groups suppressed. There is one optional assistant a workspace can turn on. When it is on, it answers from aggregate figures a caller could already see, such as headcount by department, which it sends to our one AI sub-processor, OpenAI, listed on the sub-processor register and not used to train on the data. No per-person or sensitive record is ever sent to an outside model or used to train one.

    BrightHR’s answer

    Ask them, and get it in writing.

If an answer of ours turns out to be wrong, it is a bug and we will fix the page. The same standard applies to anything here about BrightHR: tell us and we correct it or take it down.

Choose BrightHR if

This is the part of the page that makes the rest of it worth reading. If one of these describes you, the honest answer is that BrightHR is the better buy, and we would rather you knew it here than three months into an implementation.

  • You want a round-the-clock employment-law advice line bundled with your HR software, backed by an established consultancy, so that software and expert advice come from one place. That pairing is BrightHR's distinctive offer, and Capstan is a product rather than an advisory service.
  • Your HR questions are mostly United Kingdom employment-law questions, and having qualified advisors a phone call away is worth as much to you as the software. That is BrightHR's home ground.
  • You want a health-and-safety product and its advice line from the same vendor as your HR admin. Capstan is deliberately an HR system of record and narrower.

The part that costs us the sale

Where Capstan is the wrong choice

Not a softened version of the section above. These are requirements Capstan does not meet and is not going to meet, written down so you can rule us out in a minute rather than in a quarter. If one of them is true of you, nothing else on this page matters.

  1. You are buying HR software for the bundled employment-law advice as much as for the software. Capstan is a product, not an advisory service, and leaves the legal judgement to your own advisers.

  2. You want your HR software to compute pay and file your statutory returns. Capstan prepares inputs for a payroll partner and computes no payroll, in any country.

  3. You need your data held in the United Kingdom specifically. Capstan runs one self-contained region in the EU today, so a UK-residency requirement is not one it meets right now.

That is the list as we understand it today. If you hit a limit that is not on it, tell us: a disqualifier we did not know about belongs here more than anything else on the page.

If nothing on this page ruled us out, run it yourself.

Start free See every price